Nicole Byer Says a Casting Director Asked Her to 'Be Blacker' During an Audition

·2 min read
27th Critics’ Choice Awards, Arrivals, Los Angeles, California, USA – 13 Mar 2022
27th Critics’ Choice Awards, Arrivals, Los Angeles, California, USA – 13 Mar 2022

Matt Baron/Shutterstock

Nicole Byer is speaking out about an experience when she was told to "be Blacker" by a casting director.

"Usually, they say 'sassy, more street, more urban,'" the Nailed It! host, 36, told Laverne Cox on E!'s pre-Emmy Awards special If We're Being Honest.

"But I read [the line], and she was like, 'Can you be Blacker?'" Byer added of the uncomfortable exchange, which she said happened in her 20s. "I was just playing a fairy. And she was like, 'Be as Black as you can be. If you go too Black, I'll bring you back.'"

When Cox, 50, asked her about the casting director's race, Byer replied, "Oh, you know, she was white like the snow."

Nailed It! Season 4 Nicole Byer
Nailed It! Season 4 Nicole Byer

Netflix Nicole Byer

RELATED: Nicole Byer Shares Script on How to Talk About Racism to White Kids: 'Read It Verbatim'

Byer has used her notoriety to speak out about racism in the past, notably after George Floyd's death in 2020.

In an Instagram post shortly after Floyd's murder, the actress and comedian shared "a conversation to have with your white child."

"A good way to explain to kids #blacklivesmatter : 'you like this black lady right? She's silly? She makes you tee hee hee? You would be sad if a police officer hurt her right? Well this is the current country we live in where someone you like can be hurt by the color of their skin and people in charge aren't doing a f—ing (you can replace that with dang if ya kids are soft) thing about it."

NIcole Byer
NIcole Byer

Michael Kovac/Getty

RELATED: Stars Who Earned Multiple Emmy Nominations in 2022

Byer made history as the first Black woman to be nominated for outstanding host for a reality or competition program. After back-to-back nodsin 2020 and 2021, she's up for a third Emmy in the category this year on top of receiving a separate 2022 nomination for writing her special Nicole Byer: BBW (Big Beautiful Weirdo).

Her versatility as a performer was on display when she served as a guest judge on The Masked Singer earlier this year, stunning panelists Ken Jeong, Jenny McCarthy, Nicole Scherzinger and Robin Thicke by correctly guessing that magician duo Penn Jillette and Teller were underneath the Hydra costume.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The 74th Primetime Emmy Awards will be broadcast live next Monday at 8 p.m. ET on NBC.