“I didn’t like Meghan Markle’s dress as much as I wanted to until I saw this,” writer Amy Odell posted on Instagram on Saturday, with side-by-side shots of Meghan’s three-quarter sleeved white gown next to the dress Lopez wears near the end of her 2001 romantic comedy. The comparison also made the rounds on Twitter.
Some commenters agreed with the Odell-observed likeness between the looks, which feature similar necklines and vertical seams. “I saw this too,” one user wrote on Odell’s post while another commented, “I KNEW it seemed familiar.”
Not everyone was so sure, though, with one commenter writing, “Meghan is way better.”
- It’s the event of the decade! Be sure to keep up with all of PEOPLE’s royal wedding coverage and don’t forget to check out everything you need to know about Meghan Markle’s perfect style.
RELATED VIDEO: Yes, Meghan Markle’s Bridal ‘Messy Bun’ Was Supposed to Come Loose
Neither Lopez nor Meghan — still amid her post-wedding weekend — has mentioned the discussion. Clare Waight Keller, the British designer and Givenchy artistic director behind Meghan’s dress, told reporters it was meant to capture both “timeless” elegance and, in some of its details, a “refined modernity.”
Meghan gave Waight Keller the job in January. “It was an extraordinary moment when she told me,” Waight Keller said on Sunday. “It was an incredible thing to be part of, such an historic moment and, in fact, to have the opportunity to work with her.”
- Can’t get enough of PEOPLE’s Royals coverage? Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest updates on Kate Middleton, Meghan Markle and more!
The creative process itself evolved through “very collaborative” conversations and sketches and fittings, Waight Keller said.
She said of Meghan: “She is just exactly what you see on TV. She is just so genuine and warm and radiant. She is just glowing. And she’s a strong woman. She knows what she wants.”