• Home
  • Mail
  • Tumblr
  • News
  • Sports
  • Finance
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Answers
  • Groups
  • Mobile
  • More
Yahoo
    • Skip to Navigation
    • Skip to Main Content
    • Skip to Related Content
    • Mail
    Entertainment Home
    Follow Us
    • Oscars
    • Grammys
    • TV
    • Movies
    • Celebrity
    • Music
    • Videos
    • Movie Showtimes

    The HSBC 'We are not an island' ad only offends anti-immigration zealots

    Lianna Brinded
    Head of Finance, Yahoo Finance UK
    Yahoo Finance UKJanuary 9, 2019
    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share
    Graphic: HSBC/JWT advertising agency

    HSBC’s latest ‘We are not an island’ advert has done its job. It has got the nation discussing one of the biggest issues that is dividing our society and changing our future as we navigate the severance of our membership within the European Union.

    As part of that, it has also served as a Rorschach test to people’s responses to immigration, further illuminating how Brexit is rather a symptom of a dogged view over our borders.

    HSBC insists that the ad is not talking about Brexit but instead “reinforcing our strong belief that the things that make us quintessentially British are the things that make us inescapably international.” But it’s hard not to read the ad as a passive swipe at Brexiteers, after all, immigration was the main reason why people voted to leave the EU.

    The ad, displayed online, in newspapers, on bus stops, train platforms, and in London’s tube, is pretty simple: it positively lists British people’s favourite things that all derive from countries from across the world. From the coffee we drink, to the athletes we support, from our favourite foods, to beer we drink — it showcases how our nation of 66 million people are not just small islanders but thrive as a multicultural society that looks beyond its small borders. The video ad also serves to reinforce this message in a humorous way with British comedian Richard Ayoade:

    The ad doesn’t explicitly say anything about Britain leaving the EU but it didn’t stop Brexit supporters, especially politicians, from getting angry about campaign. For example, Patrick O’Flynn, a pro-Leave MEP called it a “really odd and ideologically aggressive advert.”

    Really odd and ideologically aggressive advert for HSBC on back of London Evening Standard. Not mentioning any services it offers just declaring "We (ie the UK) are not an island."

    We have many international links, but yes we are actually. Glad I am not an HSBC customer.

    — Patrick O'Flynn (@oflynnmep) January 2, 2019


    Others like Isle of Wight MP Bob Seely, jumped on the bandwagon with the predictable (read: lazy) route of attacking the bank, following the pro-immigration and globalist message in the ad.

    Spot on .@montie, and yes, we're part of something bigger; the world. @HSBC, perhaps #Brexit could mean higher standards in banking? https://t.co/8dxjer48BT

    — Bob Seely MP (@IoWBobSeely) January 4, 2019


    The biggest question is that why is the message offensive to anyone, other than if celebrating diversity riles you.

    British society is more divisive than ever right now. Anti-immigration sentiment led to Brexit, a greater “hostile environment” for migrants stemming from UK government policies, and a rise in race and religious hate crimes in Britain.

    This is despite immigration having little impact on public finances or any impact on unemployment, yet a huge contribution to the public purse and the workforce. In fact, migrants are more likely to be in work than native British workers.

    Sure, advertising is about vested interest in getting people to buy a product, service, or into idea for a company or organisation. HSBC, which has over 220,000 employees and makes about $50bn in profit a year, operates at the scale it does by greater blurring of borders.

    But having an ad that simply reminds the person on the street about how Britain has become rich — both financially and culturally — due to embracing a globalised society is something that Britain needs right now.

    This is an opinion piece and does not necessarily reflect the stance of the rest of Yahoo Finance UK.


    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share

    What to Read Next

    • Donald Trump slams 'Saturday Night Live' for mocking his national emergency

      Yahoo TV
    • Kim Zolciak-Biermann Comforts Daughter Over Body Insecurities But Admits 'I Paid for a Stomach'

      People
    • J.Lo redeems herself after Grammy Motown backlash with surprisingly rockin' Elvis tribute

      Yahoo Music
    • Baby Bling! Khloé Kardashian's ‘Dying’ Over True's Hoop Earrings as Stormi Rocks Diamond Chain

      People
    • Aaron Carter Warns Unnamed Alleged Stalker in Bizarre Tweets

      Entertainment Tonight
    • The Newlyweds! Miranda Lambert and Brendan McLoughlin Show Off Wedding Rings in N.Y.C.: 'She Was Beaming'

      People
    • For Biden and Pence, wildly differing receptions from international allies in Munich

      Yahoo View
    • Kathy Griffin goes after Donald Trump Jr. over Jussie Smollett joke

      Yahoo Celebrity
    • Bella Hadid Celebrates The Weeknd’s 29th Birthday as Couple Cuddles Up in Matching Camo Looks

      People
    • Don Cheadle Makes Powerful Political Statement as 'Saturday Night Live' Host

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Miley Cyrus Pretends to Smoke Her Floral Bouquet in Playful Wedding Photos

      People
    • Jim Carrey calls Trump’s birth “the real State of Emergency” in hilariously disturbing political cartoon

      Consequence of Sound
    • Meet Miranda Lambert's New Husband, A Former Model and Heroic Police Officer

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Ava DuVernay, Civil Rights Activists React To New Turns In Jussie Smollett Attack Case

      Deadline
    • An Intern at His First Day on the Job Was Among 5 Killed in Illinois Mass Shooting

      People
    • 21 Savage Talks Growing Up As an Undocumented Immigrant In New Interview

      Complex

    Vice President Pence met with silence after mentioning Trump in a speech

    julio: As he spoke to attendees of the Munich Security Conference, he noted that he was there on behalf of a "great champion of freedom and of a strong national defense." Mentioning Trump's achievements would have got him the same reaction as Trump's UN speech..

    Join the Conversation
    1 / 5

    494

    • SNL's Michael Che Says He Wants To See Trump's 'Dumbass Wall'

      HuffPost
    • Victoria Beckham looks to '70s prints, Preen influenced by dance

      Reuters
    • 'SNL' built an entire magical sketch around British showman Mika's 'Lollipop'

      Yahoo Music
    • Kenny G Explains How He Pulled Off Kanye West's Valentine's Day Surprise for Kim Kardashian

      People
    • Beyonce's Valentine's Day Look Couldn't Be More on Theme in Sassy New Photos

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Former Fox Anchor Heather Nauert Withdraws Name From Consideration to Become UN Ambassador

      Deadline
    • Meghan Markle & Prince Harry May Send 1st Child to an American School

      Yahoo View
    • Chris Pratt and Fiancee Katherine Schwarzenegger Expand Their Farm Family With Baby Lamb

      Entertainment Tonight
    • ‘True Detective’ Season 3 Just Revealed Its Villain – Here’s What It Means

      The Wrap
    • Kelly Clarkson Wows with Rousing Cover of Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper's Hit 'Shallow'

      People
    • ‘Saturday Night Live’ Cold Open – Alec Baldwin’s Trump Declares ‘Fake’ Border Emergency

      Deadline
    • Watch Mike Pence gasp when no one claps at his terrible applause line

      Mashable
    • Miranda Lambert Secretly Got Married: See Her Romantic Wedding Dress!

      Entertainment Tonight
    • In Another Blow to Physical Media, Samsung Is Done Making Blu-ray Players

      Indiewire
    • Miley Cyrus Shares More Pics from Liam Hemsworth Wedding -- Including When She Pretended to Smoke Her Bouquet

      Entertainment Tonight
    • ‘SNL’ Mocks Trump’s Press Conference, Compares Him to a Coke Addict

      Rolling Stone