Following Tests, James Cameron Admits “Jack Might Have Lived” in Titanic

Wren Graves
·3 min read
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.

The post Following Tests, James Cameron Admits “Jack Might Have Lived” in Titanic appeared first on Consequence.

The unsinkable James Cameron has admitted to a hole in his storytelling, acknowledging after a battery of lab tests that “Jack might have lived” in Titanic.

The acknowledgment comes in Titanic: 25 Years Later with James Cameron, a new one-hour National Geographic special. “We released Titanic 25 years ago,” Cameron said by way of introdu tion (via Rolling Stone). “But, despite all our efforts to make the film as accurate as possible, there’s one thing some fans just can’t accept: They insist Jack could’ve survived if he climbed on that floating piece of debris with Rose.”

In order to prove his view of the matter, Cameron enlisted stunt actors Josh Bird and Kristine Zipfel, who were thought to be about the same height and weight as stars Leonardo DiCaprio (Jack) and Kate Winslet (Rose) in the 1997 blockbuster. His testing included a large body of cold water in a lab, a raft of the same size and “degree of buoyancy you see in the film,” and close monitoring of the actors’ temperatures to prevent real-life hypothermia.

The initial tests did suggest that Jack would suffer from hypothermia after only about 20 minutes — far shorter than the approximately two hours it took rescue crews to arrive. Next, Bird and Zipfel tried to fit on the raft. This did not prove easy.

Both actors were able to comfortably fit their upper bodies on the raft, but their underwater lower bodies quickly put them at risk of hypothermia. The stunt workers also tried kneeling on the debris, though it became far too unstable to keep them dry for long.

Eventually, however, Bird and Zipfel found a compromise where most of their bodies were on top of the raft and only their lower legs dipped below the waterline. This had the added benefit of allowing the actors to share body heat, and under this (admittedly difficult) scenario, Cameron believes Jack could have survived “a few hours,” which is long enough to be rescued.

Never one to give up quietly, Cameron then insisted that the actors recreate the frantic flight off the boat, including briefly sinking underwater, swimming to safety, a tussle with a fellow passenger over Rose’s life jacket, and generally “going through all the stuff” the characters did before even getting to the raft.

Here, too, however, Bird and Zipfel were able to keep their body temperatures up for a couple of hours, so long as they used an optimal body arrangement and she gave him her lifejacket to keep warm. “Final verdict: Jack might have lived,” Cameron said, “but there’s a lot of variables.”

He added, “In a well-lit experiment in a test pool, we can’t possibly simulate the terror, the adrenaline, all the things that would have worked against them. [Jack] didn’t get to run a bunch of different experiments to see what worked the best. Jack’s survival might have come at the cost of her life.”

“Based on what I know today, I would have made the raft smaller so there’s no doubt,” Cameron said.

Titanic: 25 Years Later with James Cameron debuts February 5th on National Geographic. And Cameron has another movie in theaters that you might have heard of, Avatar: The Way of the Water. It recently passed Avengers: Infinity Wars and Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens in total box office, making it the fourth-highest grossing film of all time, and giving Cameron three of the top four alongside Titanic and the original Avatar.

Following Tests, James Cameron Admits “Jack Might Have Lived” in Titanic
Wren Graves

Popular Posts

Subscribe to Consequence’s email digest and get the latest breaking news in music, film, and television, tour updates, access to exclusive giveaways, and more straight to your inbox.