Don’t Any 21st Century Christmas Records Get Any Love? Yes: ASCAP Has Kelly Clarkson Topping Its ‘New Classics’ List

There’s a secret to having a Christmas record that is successful in the 21st century: Put it out before 1970.

That’s clear from just looking at the top 10 songs each December, and knowing that Brenda Lee’s “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” hit No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for the first two weeks of this month. The song that supplanted it on the most recent chart, Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas,” is considered the relative newbie of holiday classics, but even it has its feet firmly planted in a previous millennium.

More from Variety

• Holiday Music 2023 Roundup: Caroling With Cher, Brenda Lee, Brandy, Boygenius, Alanis Morissette, Laufey, Chlöe and More

• Brenda Lee on Hitting No. 1 With 'Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree,' After Record-Breaking 65-Year Climb: 'You Can't Keep a Good Song Down'

• Mariah Carey Mops the Floor - Literally - With 'Merry Christmas One and All!' at Hollywood Bowl: Concert Review

But ASCAP has been doing its part to promote the idea that more contemporary records are able to find at least some traction during the season. To that end, the performing rights organization has been publishing a list it calls the Top 10 ASCAP New Classic Holiday Songs of the Year — recognizing only compositions that have a copyright date from 20 years ago or less — along with its regular annual ranking of all Christmas songs that have ASCAP members among the writers.

Kelly Clarkson tops this particular top 10 with “Underneath the Tree,” a co-write from Greg Kurstin from her 2013 Christmas album. She also has a second song on the list, “Santa Can’t You Hear Me,” from her followup holiday album of 2021, this one placing at No. 7.

Two Christmas songs that were released this year made the “new classics” list: “DJ Play a Christmas Song,” recorded by Cher and written by Sarah Hudson and Leland, and “Wrap Me Up” by Jimmy Fallon, Gian Stone and Meghan Trainor. (See the full lists, below.)

But when it comes to the list of the top 25 songs overall, with copyright dates stretching back into antiquity, “Underneath the Tree” barely squeaks onto that list, at No. 25. And Cher, Fallon, et al. don’t place at all, pitted against the likes of the chestnuts performed by Lee, Carey, Burl Ives, etc. So it’s clear that coming up with new holiday material — even the most successful tunes of the new crop — is far from an automatic ticket to Christmas riches.

The top ASCAP holiday song overall is the Meredith Wilson-penned “It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas,” which dates back to 1951.

Meanwhile, the two songs that are dominating the Billboard Hot 100 this year rank lower on ASCAP’s in-house list. “Rockin’ Around” is at No. 7 and the Carey tune is at No. 9.

How does “It’s Beginning…” get so far ahead of the Billboard chart leaders? ASCAP doesn’t offer any explanation for that in releasing these lists, but it’s presumed that this year, as in past years, the cutoff date for the data is early in December — which would seem to favor a track that pivots on the key phrase “beginning to look,” making it a perfect choice for AC stations that are flipping to an all-Christmas format the day after Thanksgiving.

ASCAP offers a playlist of its “new classics” here and another one of its overall holiday list here.

The two charts:

THE TOP 10 ASCAP NEW CLASSIC HOLIDAY SONGS OF 2023: 

1. “Underneath the Tree” by Kelly Clarkson and Greg Kurstin (2013)

2. “Santa Tell Me” by Savan Kotecha and Ilya Salmanzadeh (2013)

3. “Like It’s Christmas” by Gian Stone (2019)

4. “Mistletoe” by Justin Bieber and Adam Messinger (2011)

5. “Snowman” by Greg Kurstin and Sia (2017)

6. “Santa, Can’t You Hear Me” by Kelly Clarkson (2021)

7. “Cozy Little Christmas” by Ferras Alqaisi, Katy Perry and Greg Wells (2018)

8. “DJ Play a Christmas Song” by Sarah Hudson and Leland (2023)

9. “Believe” by Glen Ballard (2004)

10. “Wrap Me Up” by Jimmy Fallon, Gian Stone & Meghan Trainor (2023)

THE TOP 25 ASCAP HOLIDAY SONGS OF 2023: 

1. “It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas” by Meredith Willson (1951)

2. “A Holly Jolly Christmas” by Johnny Marks (1962)

3. “Sleigh Ride” by Leroy Anderson and Mitchell Parish (1948)

4. “Jingle Bell Rock” by Joseph Carleton Beal and James Ross Boothe (1958)

5. “Let It Snow, Let It Snow, Let It Snow” by Sammy Cahn and Jule Styne (1945)

6. “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” by Johnny Marks (1949)

7. “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” by Johnny Marks (1958)

8. “All I Want for Christmas Is You” by Walter Afanasieff and Mariah Carey (1994)

9. “Santa Claus Is Comin’ to Town” by Fred Coots and Haven Gillespie (1934)

10. “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year” by Edward Pola and George Wyle (1963)

11. “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” by Ralph Blane and Hugh Martin (1944)

12. “Winter Wonderland” by Felix Bernard and Richard B. Smith (1934)

13. “The Christmas Song” by Mel Tormé and Robert Wells (1946)

14. “Frosty the Snowman” by Steve Nelson and Walter E. Rollins (1950)

15. “Feliz Navidad” by José Feliciano (1970)

16. “White Christmas” by Irving Berlin (1941)

Best of Variety

• Oscars Predictions: Original Score – Daniel Pemberton's 'Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse' is the Dark Horse for Statuette

• Oscars Predictions: Documentary Feature – This Year's Snubs and Surprises Points to the Overdue Rule Change Needed in Branch

• New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week 

Sign up for Variety’s Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.