That's the question on fans' minds after the "Taki Taki" singer shared a video showing the faded words "Selena better w/ Cole Sprouse 4-ever" on social media Thursday.
The clip also showed a separate message reading "Selena + Juan" in the center of a heart.
"Apparently my heart was very conflicted between Juan and Cole Sprouse when I was 11," the pop singer captioned her post.
'Bachelor' Juan Pablo Reacts!
While many fans are wondering if this is real and who's Juan, America's most hated "Bachelor" Juan Pablo Galavis hilariously chimed in.
"We NEVER had a conflict," he wrote on Selena's post.
Other stars leaving comments include fellow musicians Camila Cabello and Austin Mahone.
The crazy part is Selena Gomez and Cole Sprouse were already famous by the age 11.
Before her singing career, she was on "Barney & Friends" at age 10. She starred alongside Demi Lovato in the hit children's show for two years.
After "Barney," Selena moved onto Disney's "Wizards of Waverly Place," before striking it big in movies like "Spring Breakers" and "The Dead Don't Die."
Cole Sprouse started his acting gig at the age of 6 months on "Grace Under Fire" alongside his twin brother, Dylan.
The boys landed "Big Daddy" with Adam Sandler in 1999, before getting their own show "The Suite Life of Zack & Cody."
He's now the star of "Riverdale."
This certainly doesn't look like Selena Gomez's childhood bathroom, so it's unclear if she's relieving her youth or just at a random place and it's a coincidence.
Selena hasn't cleared it up, but she may have some explaining to do if Cole's real-life girlfriend, Lili Reinhart, gets wind.