Challenge Bride Down! Jenna Compono Falls After Costars Kaycee and Nany Battle Guests for Bouquet

Lars Niki/Getty; Keith Mayhew/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty; Sonja Flemming/CBS via Getty

The Challenge's Nany Gonzalez is a real catch!

The MTV reality star served as a bridesmaid in her costar and friend Jenna Compono's wedding to fellow ex-Challenge player Zach Nichols over the weekend.

Gonzalez's girlfriend Kaycee Clark and former Challenge star Laurel Stucky were also on hand to capture the moment Compono tossed her bouquet. And as you might expect from this crew, things got competitive, with Stucky narrating the chaos as it — and then Compono herself — went down.

In a video posted to Clark's TikTok, Stucky adopted a sports announcer voice as she said, "And it's time for the bouquet, Jenna lines up, Nany's in the front, catches it — fumbles the bouquet!"

"Kaycee's in, tick tick boom 'I got yo' back!'" said Stucky once Clark jumped into action to help out Gonzalez, but then things took a turn when Clark — bouquet in hand — accidentally knocked into Compono. Stucky did not drop out of character, exclaiming, "Boom! And she hits the bride ... Jenna's down!"

RELATED: The Challenge's Jenna Compono and Zach Nichols Wed in Surprise 'Mini' Ceremony with Family

Clark, 34, captioned her TikTok, "All I do is win, win, win…no matter WHAT 😳 ….but I always got my girls back 😂" She added the hashtags #WeddingFail #BrideDown #ChallengeAccepted #BouquetToss.

She and Gonzalez, 33, shared several photos from the wedding weekend, including a sweet smooch under a neon sign reading "All you need is Love," with Gonzalez's crimson velvet bridesmaid dress complementing the red rose background and Clark's black suit jacket, bowtie and shirt over coordinating maroon high-water trousers.

RELATED: The Challenge's Jenna Compono and Zach Nichols Welcome Their First Baby, a Boy

Ex-arena football player Nichols, 34, and Compono, 29, got engaged in 2019 and welcomed son Anthony Joseph Nichols last September.

This wasn't actually their first wedding ceremony — they first tied the knot in a small gathering of family and friends in Michigan on March 13, 2021, after having to postpone the wedding they had planned for February 2021 due to COVID-19.

"Realistically, we don't know how the world is going to be next year, so our wedding isn't even promised. We didn't want to put our life on hold any longer for something that isn't promised," Compono told PEOPLE last March of deciding to go forward with their legal wedding.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Brittany Brockie Photography @brittanybrockiephotography

RELATED: The Challenge Star Nicole Zanatta Is Engaged to Partner Lauren: 'Can't Believe' It

At that ceremony, Compono wore a simple white Show Me Your Mumu gown for the special occasion, paired with "gorgeous, sparkly shoes" from Bella Belle Shoes and an Ariel Taub clutch. Nichols, meanwhile, kept his look classic in a sleek black suit.

Compono said she considered this weekend's wedding "a vow renewal" and revealed she and Nichols plan to celebrate future anniversaries on their April wedding date.

The pair, who are also The Real World alums, met while making MTV's Battle of the Exes II back in 2014.