New brewery, restaurant, full bar and beer garden is something ‘Sarasota has never seen’

Wade Tatangelo, Sarasota Herald-Tribune
Updated ·5 min read

The Sarasota team behind a successful group of local restaurants, known for their delicious pizza, burgers, and wings, has partnered with one of the region's top breweries for a major new dining and drinking destination.

This massive new brewery, restaurant, full bar, and beer garden replete with lawn games and pickleball court, will soon be opening in the burgeoning Fruitville Commons neighborhood, situated just east of Interstate 75.

Yes, when Mike Bisaha, Seth Murauskas and Josh Wilson planned their new Big Top Brewing facility opening at 3045 Fruitville Commons Blvd., they reached out to Joe Seidensticker and Joe Guli, best known for their leadership of popular Sarasota and Bradenton restaurants Oak & Stone, Libby's and Circo.

Top 10 restaurants I recommend when asked 'Where should I eat in Sarasota and Bradenton?'

10 best waterfront restaurants I love to recommend in Sarasota and Manatee

Ticket Newsletter: Sign up to receive restaurant news and reviews plus info on things to do every Friday

Big Top Brewing plans to open new Fruitville Commons facility in April

Big Top Brewing’s new facility at 3045 Fruitville Commons Blvd. in Sarasota will feature a restaurant, full bar and beer garden and serve food items such as gourmet burgers and fries.
Big Top Brewing’s new facility at 3045 Fruitville Commons Blvd. in Sarasota will feature a restaurant, full bar and beer garden and serve food items such as gourmet burgers and fries.

Business has been booming in Sarasota for Big Top Brewing, which debuted in 2013 at 6111 Porter Way and has built a loyal following with tasty, bestselling core beers such as Hazy Sky Wire New England IPA, Circus City IPA, and Hawaiian Lion Coconut & Coffee Porter as well as seasonal and limited beers like the IPA collaboration with Florida musician Damon Fowler and Finhead Lager, crafted to benefit Mote Marine Laboratory.

Big Top left the Porter Way facility in 2021 for the Lakewood Ranch taproom formerly known as Naughty Monk Brewery, renamed it Big Top Brewers Collective and began brewing their beer there as well as welcoming others to use what Bisaha described as a "mini brew hub." That same year, Big Top Brewing Company also took over Cock & Bull’s space at 975 Cattlemen Road as a taproom and live music venue with food trucks. Now, Big Top Brewing plans to open its new facility in April and begin brewing its beer there "to keep up with demand," Bisaha said.

Much more than just a place to brew beer, Big Top's new facility aims to be a community meeting spot. “Sarasota has never seen anything like this, and that gets us the most excited," Bisaha said. "We built and designed this place for family and friends to gather.”

Big Top Brewing will feature restaurant and full bar

Big Top Brewing’s new facility at 3045 Fruitville Commons Blvd. in Sarasota will feature a restaurant, full bar and beer garden and serve food items such as these wood-fired pizzas.
Big Top Brewing’s new facility at 3045 Fruitville Commons Blvd. in Sarasota will feature a restaurant, full bar and beer garden and serve food items such as these wood-fired pizzas.

In addition to brewing and serving its beloved beers, Big Top's new facility will feature a restaurant, full-liquor bar and beer garden with lawn games and a pickleball court. Seidensticker and Guli have crafted food and drink menus that should appeal to the customer base they built at Oak & Stone, Libby's and Circo without using the same recipes. "It’s really elevated brewery food," Seidensticker said.

Highlights of the menu include wood-fired pizzas with hand-pulled mozzarella and other artisanal toppings, a signature burger with a brisket blend and Manchego cheese as well as a vegan option consisting of a house-made falafel patty, 24-hour house-brined wings, and tacos such as the Cubano with mojo pork and Nashville Hot with tofu.

There are also a bunch of "beer bites" such as Giant Chicken Meatballs, Bavarian pretzel, Tex-Mex egg rolls, mezze platter, and spicy tuna served on top of crispy sushi rice. There are salads, too, in addition to "kitchen specialties" such as crispy chicken breast served with pesto, pasta and Parmesan cream sauce, as well as a barbecue platter for two featuring Hazy Sky Wire-braised 48-hour ribs, and Carolina Gold BBQ pulled pork.

While most Big Top guests will want to pair their food with locally brewed beer, there are wine and cocktail options such as a margarita that the menu describes as a "balancing act between sweet and tart." Other mixed drinks include a daiquiri that is "strong and punchy, just like Ernest Hemingway," and a smoked old fashioned laced with locally sourced honey.

"For me and Joe (Guli), it's really exciting to bring the food and management aspect to this unique space that is groundbreaking for this area," Seidensticker said. "We know what we want to see at these places and this is our hometown, in our backyard, and we wanted to knock this one out of the park."

Big Top Brewing's new facility to feature massive beer garden with live music, lawn games and pickleball court

Big Top Brewing’s new facility at 3045 Fruitville Commons Blvd. in Sarasota will feature a restaurant, full bar and beer garden and serve food items such as this mezze platter paired with craft cocktails.
Big Top Brewing’s new facility at 3045 Fruitville Commons Blvd. in Sarasota will feature a restaurant, full bar and beer garden and serve food items such as this mezze platter paired with craft cocktails.

Big Top's new facility will seat nearly 700, with 200 inside and 500 outside in the 28,000-square-foot beer garden featuring two huge oak trees. There will be everything from 30 televisions to three big fire pits at Big Top, as well as live music, including local bands and dueling pianos.

For additional activities, guests can play cornhole or bocce ball, with feather bowling, a game played with wooden balls shaped like cheese wheels, an option that the owners are considering for the future. Finally, Big Top will offer guests a court for pickleball, which has become one of the country's fastest-growing sports.

Talking to Bisaha, though, he sounds most excited about the food that he will be able to pair with his acclaimed beers. In fact, he's most excited about the pizza and the meatballs.

"Those are things out of our realm of expertise, which is why we wanted to partner with Joe and Joe to put out food that represents the beer well, and beer that represents the food well," Bisaha said. "We wanted to make sure our world-class beer could be paired with exceptional food."

Fingers crossed, Big Top's new brewery will indeed open in April following more than two years of what Bisaha described as encountering every delay hurdle imaginable. Regardless of the wait time, though, it should be worth it and live up to its billing as something unlike what Sarasota currently offers for lovers of beer, food, and, well, pickleball.

Wade Tatangelo is Ticket Editor for the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, and Florida Regional Dining and Entertainment Editor for the USA TODAY Network. Follow him on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. He can be reached by email at wade.tatangelo@heraldtribune.com. Support local journalism by subscribing.

This article originally appeared on Sarasota Herald-Tribune: New brewery, restaurant, bar and beer garden opening in Sarasota