During the latest episode of their Pod Meets World rewatch podcast, a fan asked if any of the cast members were crushing on each other during the ABC sitcom's run from 1993 to 2000.
"I'll go first," said Fishel, who played Topanga Lawrence. "I had a crush on Rider [Strong]."
"That's not true," said a surprised Strong, 42, who played bad boy Shawn Hunter. "You've never told me that."
"It is too true," said Fishel, 41. Fishel, Strong and third co-host Will Friedle then joked about how Fishel kept the secret for 30 years without ever telling the object of her affection.
ABC Photo Archives/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty
Fishel was able to pinpoint exactly when she started crushing on Strong: "I think it started maybe later in season 1 and definitely through season 2," she recalled. "I did. I had a crush on Rider. I don't know — he was so smart."
She continued, "You know one of my favorite things about Rider, and it still stands to this day, Rider is very effusive. He will tell you how he feels and he's very free with his compliments, but he doesn't throw them out willy-nilly. When Rider compliments you it is thoughtful, it has meaning, and you can tell ... it's coming from a very real place."
"There was literally I think one moment where Ben and I looked at each other after we had been working together for like two years and were like, 'Are there feelings there?'" she said. "And then we went out to dinner, and we were like, 'No!'"
The actress is now married to Jensen Karp. She tied the knot with the Drop the Mic executive producer in 2018.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free weekly newsletter to get the biggest news of the week delivered to your inbox every Friday.
Boy Meets World is currently streaming on Disney+.