Heidi Klum and Shay Mitchell Jump Into the Same Saucy Jumpsuit

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
In this article:
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)
Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)

Jumpsuits are making a return to the red carpet this summer with several leggy ladies trying out the trend. The multi-functional look, which edges on casual yet chic, can be difficult to pull off without the right body type, but both Heidi Klum, 40, and Shay Mitchell, 27, showed that the right cut can make the difference.

The stunning stars hit events nearly a year apart in the same two-tone number. Mitchell debuted the look first at the 2013 Teen Choice Awards in August 2013 and Klum followed suit on Saturday at the Hamptons magazine summer party at the Southampton Social Club.

Despite their different soirees, the two women accessorized their looks to perfection, making it difficult to crown a winner in this week's fashion faceoff.

What they wore: A black and white Jenny Kayne Resort tuxedo jumpsuit, featuring a plunging neckline and retailing at $495.

How they styled it:The Pretty Little Liars star amped up the sexy factor by leaning on her natural beauty. She styled her long tresses in beach waves worn in a deep part to one side and highlighted her bronzed, natural skin with a nude lip and charcoal-lined eyes.

Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)
Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)

Klum packed a patriotic punch, pulling her hair back into a perky half-up-half down style and adding a cherry red pop of color on her lips, giving the German an all-American look ideal for Memorial Day weekend. She rimmed her hazelnut eyes with a warm brown liner and gold highlighter and powdered a little rouge on her cheeks.

The neckline of the daring jumpsuit is where things get interesting. The America's Got Talent judge, who almost never shies away from a décolletage-baring ensemble, used a black tie to cinch the white panels together to get the suit to fit correctly.

Mitchell boldly wore the look as it was originally designed and let the white paneling separate naturally, showing off her enviable bod. The suit looked like it was tailor made for her: It hugged her waist with the cummerbund midsection and didn't show any signs of pinching.

The brunette babe accessorized with a Kimberly McDonald ring and nude nails. Meanwhile, Klum went for a simple white and gold watch and a clear polish.

Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)
Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)

In the footwear department, Klum kicked up her feet in a pair of white heels while Mitchell added a pop of color with gold Jimmy Choo "Anouk" snakeskin pumps.

Judge's scorecard: It is hard to outdo a near-flawless supermodel, but young upstart Mitchell pulled it off without a hitch. The ABC Family beauty, who is known for playing a high school cutie, showed off her sophisticated side and looked confident in the mature style. Shay wins this week's fashion faceoff!

The full look:

Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)
Heidi Klum vs. Shay Mitchell. (Credit: Getty Images)