Don't let the tight pants fool you.
Following their storybook ending from the season finale of The Bachelorette, Katie Thurston and Blake Moynes appeared on Good Morning America together to discuss their love story and why Thurston, 30, feared she was going to leave the show without a fiancé.
"I truly did not think he was going to propose and then when he actually got down on one knee and proposed, my reaction was actual shock," she explained.
.@katiethurston finds love on @BacheloretteABC! After last week’s shocking departure, Katie’s journey led to a happy ending on Monday night’s season finale with an engagement to Blake Moynes.#TheBachelorettehttps://t.co/v3Gb6CX4W9 pic.twitter.com/y3voch9s21
— Good Morning America (@GMA) August 10, 2021
Thurston said that while she was confident in Moynes' feelings for her, she wasn't positive that he would get down on one knee — especially given his wardrobe choice for the occasion.
For more on why Katie Thurston didn't believe Blake Moynes was going to propose and other top stories, listen below to our daily podcast PEOPLE Every Day.
"He walked up, he had tight pants on and I looked at the pockets and there was no box and I was like 'Oh no,'" Thurston said on GMA. " And when he said the line, '[I can't give you what you came here for]' I was just trying to not give away that I was so sad."
Watch the full episode of People Features: The Bachelorette on PeopleTV.com or on the PeopleTV app.
The two then laughed as Moynes revealed the ring was in his back pocket the entire time.
He added that he was "freaking out" with nerves prior to popping the question, but "she just was everything I thought she was going to be."
Craig Sjodin/ABC Blake Moynes and Katie Thurston
Now, Thurston and Moynes said there's "no doubt" a wedding is on the way following their romantic engagement. However, they ensure roses won't be included in the decor as Moynes joked, "I'm done with them."
The couple recently opened up to PEOPLE about enjoying the time they've had away from the cameras since filming The Bachelorette, saying that they're "more in love" than ever as they continue to get to know each other.
"We think the same way about the world," Thurston said. "Blake is passionate and funny and I feel so confident in what we have. I'd do it all over again if it meant I'd get to be with him."