Arie Luyendyk Jr. is the latest celebrity to praise the powers of breast milk.
“Okay, so this is a bit of a sensitive subject, but — I don’t know if I have pink eye, but my eye is red,” Luyendyk, 37, says in a video on his Instagram Stories. “You can’t really see it because it’s like dark in here, but Lauren said that breast milk is actually a remedy for that. So I looked online and actually, it does say that.”
And while a quick Google search on the subject does result in plenty of parenting blogs suggesting breast milk as a home cure for babies and children, the American Academy of Ophthalmology says that “there is no science that supports using breast milk for pink eye and it could be more harmful than helpful.”
“I’m all about the home remedies,” Luyendyk quips in the video.
The two then swap the phone so that Burnham, 27, could film while pouring her breast milk into Luyendyk’s eye — which up close, does appear much redder than his other one. But despite her best efforts, the mother of one spills the breast milk all over her husband’s face and pokes him in the eye with the spoon she was using.
“I’m looking at your eye so I don’t poke you in the eye… meanwhile, I poke you in the eye,” Burnham narrates in the video.
The recently wed couple then break down into laughter, with Luyendyk writing atop the video, “That’s all for tonight folks… we are weird.”
Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Parents newsletter.
On Tuesday morning, the former reality star shared an update on the breast milk saga.
“All right guys, look, it’s almost completely gone,” he says of the redness in a video, bringing the camera close to his eye — which definitely appears less red than it did in the previous videos.
“Which is wild, so it worked!” he concludes.
Luyendyk isn’t the first celeb to use breast milk as a cure-all home remedy.
“If they had something in their eyes, I’d put milk in their eyes. Before their flight, I would get a dropper and put milk up their nose … to [ward off] the bacteria on the plane,” she said of her kids.
The supermodel added that she loved using breast milk so much that she stockpiled as much as she could after she stopped nursing — she even added it to her children’s cereal.
“My pediatrician said, ‘If you could bottle [it], this would be like the perfect medicine for everything,’ so I actually had a bunch frozen after I stopped breastfeeding,” she said. The mother of two admitted, “I mean, I was one crazy person, but I felt like it was such a gift that I had.”