Anderson Cooper Was All of Us with His Hilarious Reactions as He Took Shots to Bid 2020 Farewell

CNN Andy Cohen and Anderson Cooper

Anderson Cooper is saying goodbye to 2020 — but maybe not in the least painful way.

The CNN anchor, 53, took shots on live television Thursday night as he celebrated New Year's Eve alongside his friend and fellow television personality Andy Cohen, and his reactions got more hilarious the later into the night they went.

"I have not had a shot since, I think, the last time we were here," Cooper told Cohen, 52, before their first drink.

After they took the shot, Cooper pursed his lips and coughed in seemingly slight discomfort, though he otherwise held it together.

"You're getting better at it! I would argue that you're getting better at it," the Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen host told his pal.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

RELATED GALLERY: See the Most Stunning New Year's Eve Celebrations from Cities Around the World

In a series of videos shared by Twitter user CJ Fogler, Cooper made what Fogler called "bird noises" after their second shot, throwing his head back and appearing to inhale deeply.

The guys then took another shot with Stephen Colbert, who joined them via a video call from his home, and Cooper didn't hold back his distaste, shaking his head vigorously and eventually putting his forehead in one hand as Cohen laughed.

"That's delightful. That's lovely," said Colbert, 56, asking Cooper, "And how many of these have you done now, Anderson?"

As Cooper remained speechless while he continued to recover, the Bravo star told their guest, "About five, I think, maybe. Four or five."

RELATED VIDEO: Andy Cohen Says He's Waiting for Retaliation After Posting Shirtless Photo of Anderson Cooper

Andy Cohen Says He's Waiting for Retaliation After Posting Shirtless Photo of Anderson Cooper

Andy Cohen adds that Mariah Carey has "major" shady moments coming out in her book and that he's a big fan of Garcelle Beauvais

Thursday night was definitely a departure from regular life as of late for Cooper, who became a dad last year to son Wyatt.

During an appearance on SiriusXM's Quarantined with Bruce last month, the television journalist spoke with host Bruce Bozzi about life as a new dad. Cooper welcomed his first child via surrogate on April 27, and co-parents the baby boy with his former partner Benjamin Maisani.

"I don't think I would have made the decision if I didn't feel I was really ready, and I definitely feel like this is absolutely what I should be doing. I wish I had done it sooner," he said. "I've been able to spend whole days, all my time with him really, during this pandemic. It's been amazing."

"I've never woken up early in the morning, but I now bolt out of bed at 7 without an alarm clock and I want to be there when he wakes up at 8:45," added Cooper of how his life has changed since entering fatherhood. "I just love every aspect of it. It's truly the greatest thing ever. I feel like what was I doing before? I don't know."