Anderson Cooper Spits Out Drink When Gayle King Prods Andy Cohen About His BFF's Feelings on Threesomes

Cohen once claimed he and Cooper would have "some good threesomes" if their relationship ever made it out of the friendzone

Andy Cohen is calling out Anderson Cooper and his bedroom escapades!

On Monday’s episode of Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, the CNN broadcaster, 56, was put in the hot seat during a segment of “Dwheel Breakers,” a game where guests are asked intimate questions about their dating deal breakers.

Cohen, 55, started his line of questioning with a few easy questions. When the Bravo mogul asked his friend if he would date “someone who talks about how his mom is his best friend” the Anderson Cooper 360° host shrugged, “Yeah, sure.”

Cooper claimed he would break things off with someone who asked for a “personal sex tape.” When Cohen asked how he would react to a potential suitor asking to “bring a third into the bedroom,” the journalist answered with a resounding “no,” though the Housewives aficionado wasn’t so convinced.

"Oh, really? Okaaaaay, I forgot we're on TV,” Cohen quipped with a sarcastic grin.

Related: Andy Cohen Says He and Anderson Cooper 'Could Have Some Good Threesomes'

Shortly after, Cooper shared whether or not he "likes baby talk in the bedroom,” “excessive nipple play” and if he would date someone “more than 20 years your junior.”

As the giggles subsided and Cohen pushed the “Dwheel” away, fellow guest Gayle King said, “Andy, can I ask why you know that Anderson is open to threesomes in the bedroom?”

The question caught Cooper off guard and as a result, the 60 Minutes correspondent spit out his drink, leaving a stain on the carpet.

Related: Andy Cohen Says 'Daddy Needs Help' When It Comes to Dating — and Wants BFF Anderson Cooper on Tinder!

“You okay, dear?” King laughed, placing a hand on Cooper’s shoulder. “Clean up on aisle three!”

“The control room is freaking out in my ear because they know I’m silently freaking out,” Cohen added before answering King. “Just because … mother’s intuition.”

Related: Anderson Cooper and Andy Cohen's Friendship Timeline

This isn't the first time Cohen has joked about threesomes in reference to Cooper.

While speaking with Sherri Shepherd  in May about his new book The Daddy Diaries: The Year I Grew Up, the Bravo executive dove into what a relationship with Cooper might look like.

Shepherd asked if single dad Cohen is still thinking about marriage — and mentioned Cooper in the process. "We could have some good threesomes, me and Anderson," he mused before clarifying that the two were "truly just friends."

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Though their relationship has never crossed their friendship threshold, Cohen joked they could explore a "throuple" situation if all else failed.

"We've gotten so much closer over the years. I love him to death," he said. "It's so fun being a part of a duo…. We've toured the country — 50+ cities — and obviously we're on New Year's Eve every yearand we just have so much fun. And I love him and I love making him giggle! It just makes me really happy."

For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!

Read the original article on People.