American Pie Cast Reunites on Fox's Outmatched — Watch Sneak Peek

Hide your flutes and lock up your friends’ moms, because Alyson Hannigan and Eddie Kaye Thomas are coming over for a visit. The American Pie stars reunite with former co-star Jason Biggs on Thursday’s episode of Outmatched (Fox, 8:30/7:30c), and TVLine has an exclusive first look at their, ahem, American Reunion.

Hannigan and Thomas play Beth and Sigmund, a couple that the Bennetts attempt to befriend — with alcohol, naturally — in the clip above. “Sorry if we’re being weird,” Kay tells Beth and Sigmund after she and Mike lure them into their basement. “We’re just out of practice making friends. I think we’re just trying too hard.”

More from TVLine

• Pilot Season 2020: Productions Hit Pause Due to Coronavirus Concerns

• Fall TV Upfronts: CW, Fox and ABC Join CBS and NBC in Scrapping Live Events

• The Masked Singer Recap: Check Yourself Before You T-Rex Yourself

But as you’ll see, the Bennetts aren’t the only ones whose social skills have gotten a little rusty. When Mike asks his new friends what they want to do, Beth admits, “It’s been a long time somebody asked us that. We just spend most of our time focusing on what [our son] Atticus wants.” (Hell, Sigmund doesn’t even really need glasses — their son just prefers that his father wear them.)

Hit PLAY on the video above to enjoy a slice of OutMatched‘s American Pie reunion, then drop a comment with your thoughts below.

Best of TVLine

• Watch Impeachment Trial Live Stream

• Great Scott! Counting Down The Office's Top 32 Most Memorable Michael Moments (Day 4)

• Great Scott! Counting Down The Office's Top 32 Most Memorable Michael Moments (Day 3)

Sign up for TVLine's Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.