Adding Uzbekistan To Trump's Travel Ban Wouldn't Have Prevented The NYC Attack

Willa Frej

The White House used the deadly attack in lower Manhattan this week to re-route the conversation back to President Donald Trump’s travel ban, hinting that the administration may consider adding Uzbekistan ― where perpetrator Sayfullo Habibullaevic Saipov emigrated from ― to the list of targeted countries.

“Look, that’s maybe something that’s looked at, but that isn’t something that we’ve called for at this time, but we certainly haven’t ruled it out,” press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said during Wednesday’s briefing.

A look at recent terror incidents in the U.S. demonstrates, however, that a blanket ban on non-visa holders from Muslim-majority countries (the latest iteration of which was temporarily struck down in federal court last month) wouldn’t have successfully kept the terror threat out of the country, according to experts.

A third of the foreign-born perpetrators of attacks in the past few decades immigrated to the U.S. legally, making the travel ban argument moot because it wouldn’t have stopped people with green cards and visas from coming in. And besides, the threat that someone born abroad will commit an attack on U.S. soil remains minuscule.

“If the death toll from the New York attack doesn’t rise, a total of 3,037 people have been murdered on U.S. soil by 182 foreign-born terrorists from 1975 through October 31, 2017,” Cato Institute immigration policy analyst Alex Nowrasteh wrote on Wednesday. “Of those 182 foreign-born terrorists, 63 initially entered with green cards.”

This means, he added, that those who did enter the country legally have killed about 0.5 percent of all people who have died in terror attacks on U.S. soil carried out by a foreigner.

And although some 1,500 Uzbek nationals have left the country to fight with terror groups in Iraq and Syria, according to a Soufan Center report, the country’s risk of exporting terror remains low. Only three terrorists born in Uzbekistan attempted attacks on U.S. soil between 1975 and 2016, Nowrasteh added, and no one was killed.

The Trump administration has been working with countries around the world to strengthen vetting capabilities, according to the September presidential memorandum announcing the newest ban. It determined that Chad, Iran, Libya, North Korea, Somalia, Syria, Venezuela and Yemen didn’t meet the demanded information-sharing criteria.

Uzbekistan, however, fully complied with the administration’s requests, otherwise it may have been included in the ban in the first place.

“If Uzbekistan was to be added to this list, it would be even more readily apparent that that really is what’s happening here ― that the president is the one driving the outcome and not an objective set of criteria developed by experts in immigration vetting, David Bier, an immigration policy analyst at the Cato Institute, told HuffPost.

But, as Trump’s repeated demands for “extreme vetting” illuminate, experts say the problem isn’t with a lack of vetting but with how to prevent people from becoming radicalized once they’re in the U.S.

“Can we determine who might later radicalize at the time we do that screening and vetting?” asked Theresa Brown, director of immigration policy at the Bipartisan Policy Center. “And the answer is not very well, frankly, because we’re talking about future impact.”

Elise Foley contributed reporting.

Also on HuffPost

Investigators inspect the truck. 
Investigators inspect the truck. 
Investigators inspect the truck.
Investigators inspect the truck.
Emergency crews at the the scene of a violent incident on West Street in Manhattan, New York City.
Emergency crews at the the scene of a violent incident on West Street in Manhattan, New York City.
Multiple bikes crushed along a bike path in lower Manhattan.
Multiple bikes crushed along a bike path in lower Manhattan.
First responders assist a woman injured on the bike path.
First responders assist a woman injured on the bike path.
First responders tend to a victim. 
First responders tend to a victim. 
A police officer at the scene.
A police officer at the scene.
A body covered on West Street in Manhattan.
A body covered on West Street in Manhattan.
Emergency personnel at the scene. 
Emergency personnel at the scene. 
Police gather at the scene after reports of multiple people injured after a truck plowed through a bike path in New York City. 
Police gather at the scene after reports of multiple people injured after a truck plowed through a bike path in New York City. 
The truck drove down a popular biking path in lower Manhattan. 
The truck drove down a popular biking path in lower Manhattan. 
State Police stand near the scene of a pickup truck attack, on West Street in Manhattan, New York, U.S., October 31 2017. REUTERS/Andrew Kelly
State Police stand near the scene of a pickup truck attack, on West Street in Manhattan, New York, U.S., October 31 2017. REUTERS/Andrew Kelly
Security forces cordon off the area.
Security forces cordon off the area.
New York Fire Department (NYFD) and New York Police Department (NYPD) vehicles sit parked on a blocked off street.
New York Fire Department (NYFD) and New York Police Department (NYPD) vehicles sit parked on a blocked off street.
New York City Police Department (NYPD) officers on Chambers Street surround the rented Home Depot Inc..
New York City Police Department (NYPD) officers on Chambers Street surround the rented Home Depot Inc..
A pickup truck used in an attack sits on the intersection of West and Chambers Street.
A pickup truck used in an attack sits on the intersection of West and Chambers Street.

Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.