The 14 Best Loafers of 2023, Including the Pair Recently Seen on Selena Gomez
- Oops!Something went wrong.Please try again later.
Dotdash Meredith and Yahoo Inc. may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below.
With fall right around the corner, it’s time to stock up on our favorite versatile shoe
We’re big fans of fashion finds that combine both style and comfort, and the iconic loafer is certainly up there on our list of must-have shoe styles for this reason. Loafers combine dressy and sophisticated with casual and cool, making them one of the most — if not, the most — versatile shoe styles in any given wardrobe. If you need some quick inspiration, though, just look to Selena Gomez, who was recently spotted in the $103 Gabine leather loafers from fast-fashion brand Charles & Keith.
Instagram @selenagomez
Nevertheless, the beauty of loafers is that, while they have some distinct details, the shoe can really transform to meet a variety of styles, including flats, boots, and even sneakers. So, no matter what your personal style or preference might be, there is a loafer out there for you.
“Think of them as the perfect hybrid between a dress shoe and a casual shoe, allowing you to look your best without compromising on comfort,” says John Smith, a textile designer and fashion stylist. “Loafers are also a great way to add a little sophistication to any outfit and can easily be dressed up or down, depending on the occasion.”
With popularity comes oversaturation, especially in fashion, so finding a pair of loafers you love can take a little bit of digging. Luckily for you, we spent the time looking in every corner of the internet and carefully analyzing dozens of styles to find the best loafers on the market this season.
Keep reading to discover the best loafers for fall 2023, including Selena Gomez’s.
Best Celeb Favorite: Charles & Keith Gabine Leather Loafers
Who It’s Good For
These reasonably priced loafers feature a classic silhouette, chunky metal accents, and are made from genuine leather — plus, Selena Gomez has them in her closet!
Who It’s Not Good For
Some may be looking for a loafer at an even more affordable price point or may be avoiding buying shoes made from genuine leather.
Recently donned by Selena Gomez herself, these stylish loafers feature all the trending elements for this upcoming fall season: a classic silhouette, buckle detailing, and a square-toe design. Priced at around $100, this pair feels just as high-quality as its more expensive designer counterparts. For example, they’re actually constructed from genuine calf leather and feature interlocking U-shaped buckles that completely elevate the look of the shoe.
Available in black, chalk, and houndstooth versions, these offer a sense of versatility and functionality that will get you through fall and beyond. Complete the look by pairing them with the matching Gabine leather crossbody bag, which currently retails for $136.
Price at time of publish: $103
Size Range: 5-11 | Heel Height: 1.2 inches | Construction: Calf leather
Best Budget: Amazon Essentials Women's Loafer Flat
Who It’s Good For
Anyone needing a basic loafer at a super reasonable price will appreciate this pair from Amazon (and they’re also part of Amazon’s Try Before You Buy program).
Who It’s Not Good For
Because they’re so inexpensive, these aren’t made for durability; if you’re looking for a loafer you can wear for seasons to come, there are better options on this list.
For a budget-friendly loafer style that doesn’t sacrifice quality, consider the Amazon Essentials Women’s Loafer Flat. These flats are inspired by loafers but have a pointed toe and low heel (that’s functionally inexistent). Aside from their looks, we recommend these shoes because they cost less than $25 and come in an impressive range of sizes and colors (we love the gold version!), which includes options for wide feet, too.
They also come highly recommended by over 8,000 Amazon customers for their lightweight design, comfort, and value. Last but not least, this shoe style is part of Amazon’s Try Before You Buy Program, so you can order multiple sizes and/or colors to try out and only pay for what you keep.
Price at time of publish: $22
Size Range: 5-15 (wide sizes available) | Construction: Polyurethane
Best Heeled: Universal Thread Maisy Loafer Heels
Who It’s Good For
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly loafer heel with a memory foam insole, you’ll be more than satisfied with this Universal Thread pair that’s available at Target.
Who It’s Not Good For
Anyone looking for a pair of heeled loafers with higher quality construction or a pair made from genuine leather will prefer other options on this list.
When shopping online at Target, you don’t have to search long to find exactly what you need — and rest assured they’ll be as stylish as they are relatively wallet-friendly. These heels boast all the standard loafer details, from the leather-look upper and penny-keeper tongue.
Despite them being one of the most affordable options we recommend, they still provide solid function and comfort, thanks to their memory foam insoles and treaded soles, which together make them a great all-day pair of heels.
Price at time of publish: $39.99
Size Range: 5-12 | Heel Height: 2.55 inches | Construction: Leather
Best Lug Sole: Franco Sarto Franco Balin Lug Sole Penny Loafer
Who It’s Good For
These chunky lug sole loafers feature a classic penny loafer design, great traction, and cushioned insoles, making them a comfortable option for those who deal with foot pain.
Who It’s Not Good For
Someone shopping for a lug sole loafer in a more minimalistic design may prefer other pairs on this list.
Lug soles add a nice texture to the classic loafer style and we adore this under-$75 option by Franco Sarto. The Balin loafers feature a chunky lug sole and about a 1.5-inch heel that adds plenty of height and traction. With the breathable lining and extra-cushioned footbed, they also offer stellar comfort to boot. Aside from function, the shoes are also super stylish, with the patent accent, contrast stitching, and penny-keeper detail at the vamp — they will surely turn heads and capture hearts.
Price at time of publish: $57 (orig. $99)
Size Range: 5-11 | Heel Height: 1.57 inches | Construction: Synthetic leather
Best Metallic: Nine West Garren Lug Sole Loafers
Who It’s Good For
If you're wanting to partake in the silver frenzy this fall, these under-$100 metallic loafers are for you.
Who It’s Not Good For
Some may prefer a less chunky style than these lug-soled loafers.
Add a bit of sophisticated shimmer to your wardrobe with these Garren lug sole loafers from Nine West. These glossy loafers boast a ‘90s punk rock aesthetic and feature a comfortable 1.5-inch heel so they aren’t too tall yet still give you a little bit of height.
They’re also a solid option if you’re having to commute in less-than-ideal conditions, since they have a toothy lug sole for added texture and traction. If you’re not feeling bold enough for the silver, they’re also available in classic black as well as a moody red hue that’s perfect for fall.
Price at time of publish: $89
Size Range: 5-12 | Heel Height: 1.5 inches | Construction: Synthetic
Best Classic: G.H. Bass Women's Whitney Weejuns Laofer
Who It’s Good For
These classic leather loafers are hand-sewn in El Salvador and feature the iconic penny loafer design the heritage brand is known for.
Who It’s Not Good For
Someone looking for classic style loafers at a more budget-friendly price point, or someone shopping for vegan leather loafers.
Everything about the G.H. Bass Whitney Weejuns Loafer feels classic and timeless — and PEOPLE’s Senior Shopping Editor Erika Reals has proof to back it up. One of her absolute favorite pairs of loafers (she owns too many pairs to count at this point), these slip-on shoes are constructed from genuine leather (that are expertly handcrafted in El Salvador) and have an overall dressy design that styles flawlessly with a pantsuit for the office.
However, they can also complement a pair of jeans and a T-shirt quite effortlessly, making them a super versatile staple in your wardrobe. While they are a bit of an investment, these loafers are a pair of shoes you’ll be able to wear forever, given the nature of their classic beefroll design and quality handmade construction.
Price at time of publish: $175
Size Range: 5-11 | Heel Height: 0.83 inches | Construction: Leather
Best Mules: Birdies The Phoebe
Who It’s Good For
If you're in the market for a pair of luxe mule loafer slippers, you'll fall in love with this comfortable offering from Birdies.
Who It’s Not Good For
Some may prefer the full loafer look (as opposed to a mule) or may be wanting something a little more budget-friendly (if so, check out the Fericzot Slip On Mule Backless Loafers Flats).
A velvet loafer slipper such as The Phoebe Black Velvet Faux Fur Slippers from Birdies adds a touch of luxury to your loungewear look (or let’s face it — for your late-night grocery store run). We adore these slippers because they are a mule style, making them easier to slide in and out of, and they feature a faux fur lining for added warmth. The slippers also have a little bit of a heel (precisely 1 inch) and an outsole made of rubber so if you wanted to wear them out, you totally could. In fact, we recommend it.
Price at time of publish: $85
Size Range: 5-12 | Heel Height: 1 inch | Construction: Rubber, velvet, faux fur
Best Mules, Less Expensive: Fericzot Slip On Mule Backless Loafers
Who It’s Good For
This pair of velvet loafers is designed in a flat style with some added flair — and are available for under $50.
Who It’s Not Good For
Someone who prefers a more classic loafer look should look to other recommendations.
Add some flair to your wardrobe with the Fericzot Slip On Mule Backless Loafers Flats from Amazon. These velvet loafers are super fun with their monochrome design and pom pom detail. Plus, they’re super practical thanks to their durable slip-resistant rubber sole. In addition to their design, the shoes also come in lots of bright colors — including hot pink, red, olive green, and a gorgeous rose purple color — making them a good statement piece and an easy way to add a pop of color to your look.
Price at time of publish: $41.21 (orig. $58.88)
Size Range: 5-13 | Construction: Velvet
Best Driver: Rothy’s The Driver
Who It’s Good For
This classic driver loafer is impressively machine washable and constructed from a material made from recycled water bottles.
Who It’s Not Good For
These aren’t made of leather, like most classic loafer drivers.
Rothy’s is our go-to for comfortable flats that are easy to care for and a more sustainable option — and its Driver Loafer is equally as impressive. We love this loafer because it’s constructed from recycled plastic water bottles that are spun into a stretchy and breathable fabric, giving them an eco-friendly edge.
Due to the nature of the material (and overall shoe construction), the shoes are also machine washable, so you can keep them good as new no matter how often you wear them. In addition to the fabric material, the loafers feature a durable outsole with raised nubs to give you plenty of traction while you walk. Plus, they come in a variety of fun and neutral colors, too.
Price at time of publish: $189
Size Range: 5-13 | Construction: Made from recycled plastic water bottles
Best Penny Loafer: Free People Liv Penny Loafer
Who It’s Good For
For anyone seeking a classic penny loafer style at a great discount, these Free People Liv loafers are for you.
Who It’s Not Good For
As these feature a slimmer lug sole than others on our list, some may be looking for a chunkier penny loafer style.
The Free People Liv Penny Loafer features a classic penny loafer design — but with a twist. This pretty pair is made in playful hues that you don’t typically find in penny loafers, such as cantaloupe, coral, and green apple, and also features a metal coin inside the penny slot (adorable). Despite not having a lug sole bottom, the shoes are designed with a slip resistant outsole, and they have a cushioned footbed for further support and comfort.
Price at time of publish: $51.20 (orig. $128)
Size Range: 5-11 | Heel Height: 1 inch | Construction: Leather suede
Best Loafer Boots: Charles & Keith Metallic Accent Loafer Boots
Who It’s Good For
Those going for something a bit different this fall will love these loafer-inspired boots that are currently on sale.
Who It’s Not Good For
As these are inspired by chunkier loafer styles, some may prefer a more streamlined, classic loafer boot.
If you want something a little different for fall, go for a pair of loafer-inspired boots like these ones from Charles & Keith. The Metallic Accent Loafer Boot features a chunky platform lug sole design with a shaft that stretches just beyond the ankles. Despite being constructed from faux leather, these stylish fall boots have this buttery texture that make it seem like the real thing.
In addition to transforming loafers into boots, the design also elevates the classic penny loafer design with a gorgeous geometric brooch inspired by a locking mechanism on top, adding a nice golden accent to the all-black design.
Price at time of publish: $66 (orig. $93)
Size Range: 5-11 | Heel Height: 1.96 inches | Construction: Faux leather, jersey
Best Sneaker: Matisse Bess Platform Loafer
Who It’s Good For
Someone shopping for a pair of sneakers with loafer-inspired accents and details will appreciate the comfort these bring.
Who It’s Not Good For
These are not made from genuine suede or leather which may be a preference for some.
Loafers are already super comfortable, but if you want to up the ante, a pair of sneakers inspired by loafers is the way to go. The Matisse Bess Platform Loafer is a sophisticated sneaker with a retro design and touches of loafer accents, like the tassels and chain on the top of the foot.
We love that they are a little dressier compared to most sneakers, so they boast versatile style potential, but they are also just as comfortable as your favorite running shoes, thanks to the EVA outsole, padded insole, and platform design. The sneakers also come in lots of color options, including suede black, glossy metallic gold, shimmering silver, and a soft saddle brown color — all of which would be great for fall styling opportunities.
Price at time of publish: $79.95 (orig. $95)
Size Range: 5-11 | Heel Height: 1 inch | Construction: Synthetic suede
Best Investment: Coach Leah Loafer
Who It’s Good For
These designer loafers boast a platform design that still manages to feel sleek and sophisticated.
Who It’s Not Good For
Obviously, this is the most expensive option on our list and won’t fit everyone’s budget.
If you want a pair of platform loafers but don’t want to go too sky high, consider the Coach Leah Loafer, which are on regular rotation in PEOPLE contributor Jessie Quinn’s wardrobe. These slip on shoes are designed with buttery soft leather uppers and feature a cushion memory foam padding inside for long-lasting comfort. Inspired by the ‘90s lug sole loafer, these have an element of timelessness while remaining modern and even a little trendy, thanks to the iconic C logo on top.
Price at time of publish: $195
Size Range: 5-11 | Heel Height: 1.75 inches | Construction: Leather upper and footbed; manmade leather lining
Best Mule: Aerosoles Reba Mule
Who It’s Good For
This loafer mule is made from genuine leather and features a comfortable 2.25-inch heel for added height.
Who It’s Not Good For
If you prefer a loafer mule without a heel, we recommend the Birdies slipper mule.
If you prefer a mule style loafer, our top pick is the Reba Mule from Aerosoles. This loafer slip-on comes in both a glossy black patent as well as a creamy brown and features a 1-inch platform with a 2.25-inch heel, giving you a little extra height.
Since it’s constructed from high-quality genuine leather, it will wear in easily and shape to your feet over time. Plus, the lug sole and block heel helps make you feel more sturdier on your feet as you go about your day.
Price at time of publish: $99 (orig. $125)
Size Range: 5-12 | Heel Height: 2.25 inches | Construction: Leather
How to Pick the Right Loafers
Toe Box
When shopping for a comfortable pair of loafers, look for options with a wide toe box, which allow your feet to function well while walking, says Dr. Alissa Kuizinas, a board-certified podiatrist. “If your toes are squished together at the end of the shoe, you will be much more prone to overuse of your foot muscles, arch fatigue, and foot soreness, including heel pain,” she explains.
Soles
From platform and high heels to lug soles and flats, loafers come in a variety of sole options. Dr. Kuizinas says it’s important to consider the type of sole that best fits your needs. If foot pain or support is a concern, she recommends a flat sole (versus a high heeled style) so that your body will be in a more natural alignment when you walk. “An elevated heel can push your body weight forward, causing you more strain to the forefoot and toes,” she explains. “It can also cause your toes to grip more in your shoes and, over time, can lead to ankle stiffness.”
Dr. Kuizinas says to also look for a flexible sole, which will allow your foot to move and bend naturally as you walk. “Without this, the muscles and joints in your feet can easily become stiff.”
Comfort and Fit
Fit is a key component to comfort. “Make sure the fit is snug with no gaps or tightness,” says Smith, who notes that loafers should fit like a glove and be thought of as an extension of your feet. Additionally comfort perks like padded insoles, EVA outsoles, and good traction can also make a difference in comfort and leave you feeling more stable on your feet.
Style
“Choosing a color and material that meshes with your current wardrobe is super important when hunting for loafers,” says Danielle Cafiero, a fashion stylist and wardrobe consultant. She recommends looking at black and neutral leathers if you want to maximize wear or are looking to invest in a higher priced pair. However, fun colors, patent, and embellished loafers can also elevate day-to-night dressing so, if you love the loafer style, it’s worth splurging on a fun pair, too.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should you wear socks with loafers?
When styling a pair of loafers with socks, Smith says it really depends on the occasion and your personal preference. “Generally, socks are not a requirement when wearing loafers, but it can be a great way to add another layer of sophistication,” he notes. Cafiero adds that socks are a fun way to dress up your loafer and make them more aligned with your personal style.
“Pair a chunkier knit sock with a classic horsebit style or team a thin calf-length version with both minimal and chunkier loafer options,” she adds, noting that adding a pair of calf socks over sheer tights can elevate the preppy skirt and loafer look.
How do you wear loafers with jeans?
Some might prefer loafers with a cropped or fitted pair of jeans, however, Cafiero says you can wear them with virtually any style, including flair. When pairing loafers with jeans, she says the most important thing isn’t the style, it’s the length of the denim. “For example, with baggier and relaxed styles, you can roll them up to expose more skin and create balance with a slim loafer,” she explains.
How long does it take to break in loafers?
According to Cafiero, it usually takes around 3 to four wears to break in a new pair of loafers. “I recommend increasing the amount of wear slowly over the course of those initial wears to stretch them out properly,” she explains.
One trick for breaking in loafers is to wear them at the end of the day when your feet are more swollen, which can stretch the shoes out to a more comfortable fit. “You can also use a blow dryer for 30 seconds to help stretch any tight-fitting areas of the loafer,” Cafiero adds.
Are expensive loafers worth it?
Expensive loafers are certainly worth it if they are a shoe you’ll get lots of wear out of. “If you’re considering investing in an expensive pair of loafers, gauge how frequently you’ll wear the loafer,” says West. She adds that, while they do come with a high price tag, expensive loafers from luxury brands are typically made from premium materials, have upgraded hardware, and even boast comfort features like padded insoles for support, which can all be worth it in the long run.
That being said, you don’t need to invest a ton of money in a new pair of loafers, especially if you’re just wanting to test the trend out. Since loafers are super trendy right now, West says you can find lots of high quality styles at a range of price points and, if you’re new to the style, it might be worth it to go for a less expensive option before making the investment.
Take Our Word For It
Jessie Quinn is a contributing commerce writer for PEOPLE and has written for publications such as Byrdie, InStyle, The Spruce, NYLON, and more. Loafers are one of Jessie’s favorite shoe styles — in fact, she owns several pairs ranging from budget-friendly to designer (Coach’s Leah Loafer is her personal favorite). When researching the best loafers, Jessie considered all the styles she has tested as well as additional options from top shoe brands to find ones with quality construction, good materials, comfort, and style. She also reached out to textile expert John Smith, fashion stylist and wardrobe consultant Danielle Cafiero, as well as board-certified podiatrist Dr. Alissa Kuizinas for their insights on what to look for when shopping for loafers. Senior Commerce Editor Erika Reals updated this story with additional options, including the pair recently spotted on Selena Gomez.
For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!
Read the original article on People.
