10 Albums for Falling In Love According to The Bachelor’s Joey and Kelsey

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.

The post 10 Albums for Falling In Love According to The Bachelor’s Joey and Kelsey appeared first on Consequence.

Crate Digging is a recurring feature that takes a deep dive into music history to turn up albums all music fans should know. In this edition, The Bachelor’s newly engaged final couple, Joey and Kelsey, talk through ten albums to score the perfect love story.

The full interview with Joey and Kelsey is also available as an episode of the Consequence UNCUT podcast. Listen below or wherever you get your podcasts.


In order to create a perfectly dramatic finale, The Bachelor requires that a few secrets are kept tightly under wraps each year. This season’s final couple, Joey and Kelsey, have been together for months now, but only just became public following the conclusion of the show’s 28th installment.

Prior to this week, the two had to stay especially tight-lipped, but they found comfort in songs like Taylor Swift’s “Dress.” “‘Our secret moment in a crowded room/ They have no idea about me and you;’ that’s exactly how I feel whenever Joey and I make eye contact,” Kelsey says. “There’s all these other women here, but it just feels like us in that moment.”

“Whenever I missed Kelsey, I told one of the producers, ‘Play that song right now,'” Joey confirms. It became a secret code for the two while navigating the inevitable drama of dating on ABC.

Now engaged, Joey and Kelsey decided to round up some of their favorite albums that make them think of love, which mostly means albums that makes them think of each other.

“I’ve shown Joey a lot of music; I’m not sure he likes it all, but we overlap on pop and country,” shares Kelsey. Joey adds, “We do both like alternative and singer-songwriter style music, but country’s been huge for me as of late.”

Read through all the picks from the couple below, or listen to the full podcast chat above.


John Mayer — Continuum

john mayer continuum artwork
john mayer continuum artwork

Joey: John Mayer’s always been my favorite artist, from the beginning. It’s kind of cliche, but one of my favorite songs is “Slow Dancing in a Burning Room.” It’s got parts of it that kind of sound sad, but I just love that song. There’s so many other ones — “Vultures,” “Gravity.” I just think that’s one of his best sounds because he also changes his music up, which I really do appreciate, but I think the sound that everyone fell in love with most was that album.

Taylor Swift — Lover

taylor swift lover artwork
taylor swift lover artwork

Kelsey: Joey posted his first post about us as a couple and used “Lover,” which is such a good song. I love Taylor Swift and we really connected on the show over the song “Dress,” which I know is on reputation, but I was listening to that song on the plane to Malta and it made me think of him; “secret moments in a crowded room.” We connected through Taylor.

Joey: No one wants to hear me belt the high note on “Lover,” but I try.

John Mayer — Room for Squares

john mayer room for squares artwork
john mayer room for squares artwork

Joey: This is my favorite John Mayer album; I’d put it over Continuum. My uncle was actually the one that introduced me to John Mayer. I remember I was pretty young, but he used to put that album on the car, the CD, and I listened to it a ton of times. There’s a lot of love songs on that album.

Daniel Caesar — Freudian

daniel caeser freudian artwork
daniel caeser freudian artwork

Kelsey: I love Daniel Caesar’s voice, and I feel like while you’re listening to it, you really feel like you’re falling in love. I have a playlist on my Spotify of all the songs that remind me of Joey, and there’s a lot of these songs on it.

Morgan Wallen — Dangerous: The Double Album

morgan wallen dangerous artwork
morgan wallen dangerous artwork

Joey: That was my Nashville stage — I think Morgan Wallen was the one that really got me into country music. He has that perfect blend, but that album alone, it’s about all the different like levels of love. There’s heartbreak in it, and he obviously has some actual love stories, too. It’s almost nostalgic for me with how I fell in love with country music.

Frank Ocean — Channel Orange

frank ocean channel orange artwork
frank ocean channel orange artwork

Kelsey: This is the Frank Ocean album that really got me obsessed with him. There’s so many great songs in here, and a lot of them make me think of mine and Joey’s love. “Thinking About You” is a classic.

John LegendGet Lifted

john legend get lifted album artwork
john legend get lifted album artwork

Joey: John Legend just exudes love when he sings. And when I’m thinking through full albums, so much of it goes back to CDs. I listened to this one on repeat. “Get Lifted” and “Ordinary People” are the ones on top of my head. I don’t know how I couldn’t have put this one on the list.

Anees — summer camp

anees summer camp artwork
anees summer camp artwork

Kelsey: I sent Joey a lot of songs from that album. I love those songs. There’s “sun and moon,” that one’s really good. Joey put it up on his story after I sent it to him, which was a little nugget out there. So many people were like, “Okay, well, whatever is going on with Joey, he’s definitely happy.”

Joey: The other one you sent that I love too was “slip.”

Maroon 5 — Songs About Jane 

maroon 5 songs about jane cover art
maroon 5 songs about jane cover art

Joey: This was one of my dad’s favorite albums. Adam Levine’s voice is so unique; I think that’s why I love Maroon 5 so much.

I met the lead guitarist, James Valentine, when I was teaching him tennis. I just straight up asked him, “Dude, why don’t you make more albums like Songs About Jane? Everyone loves that album.” And he said, “You don’t think we want to keep making songs like that?” He was awesome.

Jack Johnson — In Between Dreams

jack johnson in between dreams album artwork
jack johnson in between dreams album artwork

Kelsey: This album honestly reminds me of my childhood, and I associate it with falling in love because it makes me feel that giddy feeling when I listen to it. What it really reminds me of is driving in the car with my mom and dad and seeing their love together.

10 Albums for Falling In Love According to The Bachelor’s Joey and Kelsey
Mary Siroky

Popular Posts

Subscribe to Consequence’s email digest and get the latest breaking news in music, film, and television, tour updates, access to exclusive giveaways, and more straight to your inbox.