Who Almost Took Elisabeth Shue's Adventures in Babysitting Gig?

Screen Videos

We caught up with "Adventures in Babysitting’s" Keith Coogan via Skype to find out which 80s actresses were up for Elisabeth Shue's role. It turns out that Valerie Bertinelli screen tested for the gig, along with Phoebe Cates and Jami Gertz. Keith also recites his classic line from another cult babysitting flick, "Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's Dead," and tells us what the movie was originally titled.