11 / 11
Carol Alt
And last but not least we have Bensimon's fellow supermodel, Carol Alt. Yes, she's flawless for 51, but, no, that doesn't mean she should be wearing this salacious, S&M-inspired dress to a star-studded soiree in NYC. Just sayin'. (5/2/2012)

Follow What Were They Thinking?! creator, Matt Whitfield, on Twitter!

What to Read Next

What Were They Thinking?!

May 5, 2012

This week's worst-dressed celebs include Adrienne Bailon, Rihanna, and January Jones. -- By Matt Whitfield, Yahoo! Staff